Calcutta High Court Directs TMC MP Abhishek Banerjee to Submit List of Judges Alleged to Back BJP
The Calcutta High Court questioned Trinamool Congress MP Abhishek Banerjee over televised remarks linking certain judges to the BJP while hearing his petition against a security downgrade.
- The Calcutta High Court questioned TMC MP Abhishek Banerjee over remarks claiming certain judges are aligned with the BJP.
- The West Bengal government sought contempt action, submitting a video and transcript of Banerjee's televised interview.
- The court reserved its order on Banerjee's separate petition challenging the reduction of his security cover from Z+ to X category.

The Calcutta High Court on Thursday addressed controversial remarks made by Trinamool Congress MP Abhishek Banerjee, who had publicly accused a section of the judiciary of aligning with the Bharatiya Janata Party. Justice Krishna Rao questioned the parliamentarian's counsel during proceedings, asking for a formal list identifying which judges were allegedly associated with the political party.
The court proceedings unfolded as the bench reviewed a writ petition filed by Banerjee, challenging the reduction of his security cover from Z+ to X category. Justice Rao observed that an educated person and elected representative could not be treated like an ordinary layperson, remarking that the politician appeared to be writing the annual confidential reports of the judges.
The West Bengal government formally brought the television interview to the court's attention. Additional Advocate General Billwadal Bhattacharya, representing the state, submitted a video recording and transcript, arguing that the MP's comments amounted to criminal contempt by casting aspersions on a constitutional institution and naming a judge.
Defending the petitioner, senior advocate Shoeb Alam maintained that the remarks were an expression of exasperation following alleged attacks on Banerjee's residence in Kalighat, south Kolkata, on November 7, where his wife and children were present. Alam contended that the comments had no bearing on the security relief sought, emphasizing that his client faced multiple threats and was simply seeking the protection of his fundamental right to life under Article 21.
Despite the state's push for contempt action, Justice Rao clarified that the controversy surrounding the televised interview would not derail the core security petition. The judge noted that the writ petition should remain unaffected by external publications and announced that the bench would reserve its order after weighing all arguments.
Background on the Controversy
The legal friction followed a televised interview and public address by Banerjee on his birthday, where he claimed that his security-related petition had stalled and accused the judiciary of maintaining an awkward silence over threats he faced. The TMC leader had alleged that multiple violent incidents had occurred since June 19, including an episode at an airport where a man visible in photographs with Suvendu Adhikari allegedly tried to attack him with a gun without subsequent police action.
In his televised statements, Banerjee had expressed frustration regarding pending legal matters, stating that courts were allowing goons to gain courage by keeping cases unresolved. He asserted readiness to face imprisonment for speaking out against what he termed political anarchy and police incompetence.
Reactions and Legal Arguments
State law officers argued that political rivalries should not permit attacks on the judiciary, urging the bench to initiate suo motu proceedings. Meanwhile, Banerjee's legal team maintained that the threat perception on the ground justified an emergency review and an increase in security cover, noting that the state's failure to prevent attacks reflected a breakdown of law and order.
Political figures also weighed in on the remarks. BJP spokesperson and advocate Priyanka Tibrewal criticized the statements as shameful, asserting that no individual is above the law and that criticizing judges constitutes contempt. Conversely, lawyer and party representative Baiswanor Chatterjee pointed out public anguish surrounding pendency and delays in judicial relief, suggesting citizens often experience frustration with the system.
- Justice Krishna Rao presided over the hearing regarding Abhishek Banerjee's security plea.
- The state government argued that Banerjee's comments about judges constituted criminal contempt.
- Banerjee's defense stated the remarks stemmed from frustration over safety threats to his family.
Spotted an error? · Our editorial policy
UP NEXTDadasaheb Phalke International Film Festival Awards 2026: Taylor Swift and James Cameron Among WinnersOther angles · #Abhishek Banerjee
Timeline →More from India

YouTuber Remanded to Prison Following Re-enactment of Madurai Jewellery Heist

Khadoor Sahib MP Amritpal Singh Returns to Punjab for Grandmother’s Last Rites

Delhi Court Grants Bail in Smuggling Case, Citing Constitutional Violations Over 24-Hour Detention Limit
