Supreme Court Questions Government Over Long-Standing Judicial Appointment Reforms
The Supreme Court has issued notices to the central government and its own Secretary General following a petition regarding the decade-long delay in finalizing the appointment procedures for constitutional court judges.
- Supreme Court issued notices to the Centre and the Secretary General over the delay in finalizing the Memorandum of Procedure.
- The petition by NGO Lok Prahari cites an 11-year delay since the 2015 ruling that reinstated the Collegium system.
- The plea advocates for bringing Collegium meeting minutes under the Right to Information Act for increased transparency.

A judicial bench comprising Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale has initiated proceedings to address the protracted delay in updating the Memorandum of Procedure (MoP). This document serves as the formal framework for the elevation, appointment, and transfer of judges across the Supreme Court and various High Courts in India. The court’s action follows a petition submitted by the organization Lok Prahari, which argues that the current administrative inertia hinders the pursuit of justice.
Background of the Judicial Appointment Reform
The urgency highlighted by the petitioner stems from a landmark 2015 verdict. At that time, a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court invalidated the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, effectively reinstating the Collegium system. During that ruling, the court explicitly directed the government to finalize an amended MoP. The objective was to improve the functional transparency and overall credibility of the selection process. Although an order was issued on December 16, 2015, tasking the government with revising the framework, consistent disagreements between the executive branch and the judicial leadership have stalled progress for nearly eleven years.
The Petitioner's Primary Demands
The petition, presented by advocate Shashank Singh, contends that the existing procedural flaws negatively impact the quality of judicial appointments, thereby affecting the rights of litigants. To mitigate these concerns, the plea requests a mandatory one-month timeline for the finalization of the document. Beyond the timeline, the petitioner seeks a significant shift in administrative policy by bringing the minutes of meetings held by the Supreme Court and High Court Collegiums under the purview of the Right to Information Act. Proponents of this change argue that greater public access to these deliberations would foster essential objectivity in the selection of constitutional judges.
Procedural Developments in Court
During the recent hearing, Justice MM Sundresh addressed his position as a member of the current Collegium, questioning whether his participation in the matter might pose a conflict of interest. However, senior counsel Sanjay Hegde, representing the petitioner, advised that recusal was not necessary. Consequently, the bench proceeded to issue formal notices to both the Union of India and the Supreme Court Secretary General. These parties are now required to provide their formal responses regarding the stagnation of the reform process.
Institutional Responsibilities
The legal challenge emphasizes that the responsibility for these updates rests with both the central government and the office of the Chief Justice of India. The 2015 directive specifically required the Chief Justice to consult with the four most senior judges of the top court to form a unanimous view on the MoP. By seeking official responses, the bench aims to uncover why this cooperative task remains incomplete after a decade of legal mandates. The court’s intervention signifies a renewed focus on holding both administrative and judicial entities accountable for the structural integrity of the Indian legal system.
- Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale issued notices to the Centre and the Supreme Court Secretary General.
- The petitioner is demanding the MoP be finalized within one month to address transparency concerns.
- The petition includes a request to make Collegium selection minutes accessible via the Right to Information Act.
Spotted an error? · Our editorial policy
UP NEXTSanjay Kapoor Stars in ‘Unexpected – Safed Sach’ Based on 2024 Dehradun CaseSwipe more stories · Indian PoliticsQuick cards, a few lines each. Tap to open.More from Indian Politics

Arunachal Organisations Appeal to Amit Shah to Cancel 11,200-MW Siang Mega Dam

Former Kerala Sports Minister Named as Accused in Lionel Messi Event Probe

Parliament’s Monsoon Session Sets Record at 100 Days Unprorogued Amid Delimitation and Reservation Speculation
