Shiv Sena Protest Against Sonia Gandhi Memoir Triggers Political Backlash
A Shiv Sena press conference in Mumbai turned contentious after a leader inadvertently tore a photograph featuring party founder Bal Thackeray during a demonstration against Sonia Gandhi’s recent memoir.
- A Shiv Sena press conference protesting Sonia Gandhi's memoir resulted in the accidental tearing of a photo of Bal Thackeray.
- Shaina NC defended the act by claiming she was targeting an image of Mani Shankar Aiyar, later posting an image that was questioned as being AI-generated.
- Congress and Shiv Sena (UBT) members condemned the incident, leading to protests in the BMC and calls for disciplinary action.

A demonstration organized by the Eknath Shinde-led Shiv Sena to condemn remarks made by Sonia Gandhi in her newly published memoir has escalated into a significant political dispute. The protest, held in Mumbai, targeted specific passages in the book, Belonging: A Journey of Love, which characterize Hindutva ideologue VD Savarkar as exclusionary and suggest his involvement in historical collusion with colonial authorities.
The Incident at the Press Conference
During the event, party members including Shaina NC, Sanjay Nirupam, Sheetal Mhatre, and Anand Dubey actively tore copies of the memoir to express their disapproval. The participants also brought a historical photograph to the stage, which depicted the late Shiv Sena founder Bal Thackeray striking an effigy of former Union Minister Mani Shankar Aiyar with a slipper. This image originated from a 2004 protest regarding comments Aiyar had made about Savarkar.
While participating in the destruction of the book copies, Shaina NC inadvertently tore through the middle of the printed photograph, which included the likeness of Bal Thackeray. Video footage captured the moment, showing a colleague alerting her to the error. Shaina NC was observed whispering an apology and attempting to conceal the damaged photograph beneath other documents on the table.
Political Fallout and Defenses
The incident drew immediate condemnation from political rivals, including members of the Shiv Sena (UBT), the Congress party, and the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena. Critics characterized the act as an insult to both the legacy of the party founder and the broader identity of Maharashtra. Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Anil Parab suggested that Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde should take disciplinary action, while party MP Sanjay Raut described the individuals involved as imposters.
In the aftermath, the controversy spilled into the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation, where opposition corporators staged a walkout during a general body meeting. Responding to the backlash, Shaina NC defended her actions on social media, asserting that her intent was to target the image of Aiyar rather than Thackeray. She warned that she would pursue legal measures against those spreading what she described as false narratives regarding the incident.
To bolster her position, she released an additional high-resolution image meant to demonstrate her focus on the Aiyar portion of the photo. However, this clarification invited further scrutiny, as independent observers suggested the replacement image appeared to be generated by artificial intelligence, adding a new dimension of public embarrassment to the situation.
Broader Conflict Over Historical Memory
Congress leaders, including Balasaheb Thorat and Vijay Wadettiwar, condemned the vandalism during the protest. Thorat criticized the party for what he termed a publicity stunt, arguing that disagreements with literature should be handled through civil debate rather than destructive acts. He emphasized that the book provides an opportunity to review the life journey of Sonia Gandhi from her own perspective.
Wadettiwar alleged that the actions reflected a lack of ideological depth among those protesting, suggesting that silencing ideas through physical destruction contradicts democratic principles. Mumbai Congress president Varsha Gaikwad further questioned the loyalty and commitment of the protest participants, noting the diverse political backgrounds of those present on the platform.
The Shiv Sena maintains that Gandhi’s book disparages the soul of Hindutva and has formally demanded that the publisher, HarperCollins, remove specific passages from pages 201 and 443. As of now, the controversy continues to serve as a rallying point for opposition figures who view the handling of the protest as a symbolic failure of the current administration’s leadership.
- The protest was directed at Sonia Gandhi's book, which features critical remarks about VD Savarkar.
- The opposition has utilized the incident to attack the credibility and internal loyalty of the Shinde-led Shiv Sena.
- The controversy expanded to include accusations of AI-generated content being used to deflect from the original mistake.
Spotted an error? · Our editorial policy
UP NEXTMax Verstappen inherits Las Vegas Grand Prix pole after Kimi Antonelli penaltyOther angles · #Bal Thackeray
Timeline →More from Indian Politics

Arunachal Organisations Appeal to Amit Shah to Cancel 11,200-MW Siang Mega Dam

Former Kerala Sports Minister Named as Accused in Lionel Messi Event Probe

Parliament’s Monsoon Session Sets Record at 100 Days Unprorogued Amid Delimitation and Reservation Speculation
