RBI Files Supreme Court Review Petition Over Yes Bank AT-1 Bond Verdict
The Reserve Bank of India has filed a review petition in the Supreme Court challenging the judgment that set aside the write-off of Yes Bank’s AT-1 bonds.
- The Reserve Bank of India filed a review petition in the Supreme Court on November 13 against the October 15 judgment regarding Yes Bank's AT-1 bonds.
- The dispute involves the write-down of Rs 8,415 crore across two bond issuances from 2016 and 2017 during the lender's March 2020 reconstruction.
- Yes Bank has also filed a review petition, citing potential impacts of up to 250 basis points on its Common Equity Tier-1 ratio if the bonds are restored.

The Reserve Bank of India has moved the Supreme Court with a review petition against its October judgment that invalidated the write-off of Additional Tier-1 bonds issued by Yes Bank, valued at Rs 8,415 crore. According to apex court records, the central bank submitted its review application on November 13. Yes Bank had similarly approached the court on the same date, seeking reconsideration of the ruling under Article 137 of the Constitution.
Background of the Dispute and Judicial Rulings
The controversy stems from the rescue operations undertaken in March 2020 during a period of severe financial distress at Yes Bank. Following a government-imposed moratorium, the central bank superseded the lender's board and appointed an administrator. Although a draft reconstruction scheme initially proposed permanently writing down the capital instruments, the provision was omitted from the final notification issued by the government on March 13, 2020.
Despite this omission, the administrator proceeded to write down AT-1 bonds totaling Rs 8,415 crore on March 14. The write-down covered two specific issuances: Rs 3,000 crore issued in December 2016 with a 9.5 percent coupon, and Rs 5,415 crore issued in October 2017 with a 9 percent coupon. Axis Trustee Services challenged the action on behalf of bondholders before the Bombay High Court, which ruled in favor of investors in January 2023.
Supreme Court Judgment and Central Bank Arguments
On October 15, a bench comprising Justices Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih affirmed the High Court decision. The bench concluded that the administrator lacked the authority to execute a write-down when the final reconstruction scheme omitted the power to do so. The court rejected arguments that financial necessity could override legally prescribed procedures.
In its review petition, the central bank contended that the bench did not adequately evaluate the Basel III Master Circular governing loss-absorption mechanisms for AT-1 bonds, highlighting distinctions between pre-specified triggers and point-of-non-viability triggers. The Reserve Bank of India has requested an open-court hearing alongside a stay on the October ruling.
Capital Implications for the Lender
Yes Bank has separately sought reconsideration due to potential ramifications for its capital adequacy. The lender previously estimated that restoring the principal amount of the bonds could diminish its Common Equity Tier-1 ratio by approximately 240 to 250 basis points based on projected capital positions. Meanwhile, Axis Trustee Services has sought the reinstatement of depository and exchange records for the bondholders and indicated the possibility of initiating contempt proceedings over alleged non-compliance.
- The Reserve Bank of India and Yes Bank filed separate review petitions on November 13 under Article 137 of the Constitution.
- The Supreme Court previously upheld a Bombay High Court decision invalidating the Rs 8,415 crore bond write-off executed by the bank administrator in March 2020.
- Reinstating the bonds could affect the lender's capital ratios by approximately 240 to 250 basis points.
Spotted an error? · Our editorial policy
UP NEXTPrime Minister Narendra Modi Visits IIT Kharagpur for Platinum Jubilee CelebrationsSwipe more stories · BusinessQuick cards, a few lines each. Tap to open.More from Business

Felix Plaza in New Gurugram Expands as a Multi-Utility Retail and Entertainment Hub

Gold Drops to One-Year Low While Silver Falls Sharply Amid US Rate-Rise Expectations and Stronger Dollar

India’s Foreign Exchange Reserves Drop by $14.21 Billion to Three-Month Low
